This article was originally sent to my email list, where I share weekly thinking on building podcasts that last. You can sign up here.
One of the most common things people say to me about podcasting is some version of:
“I don’t think I’m very good at this.”
Sometimes it’s about their voice.
Sometimes it’s about their tone.
Sometimes it’s the fear that everyone else sounds more natural, more confident or more cut out for it than they do.
And almost always, that feeling gets interpreted as a sign they’re not made for podcasting.
But that feeling isn’t a warning, it’s feedback.
What “not good enough” actually means
When you’re learning something new, especially something that’s public, discomfort is part of the deal.
Podcasting asks you to:
- Hear yourself objectively so you can improve your presenting
- Think while speaking so you’re always ahead of your audience
- Keep to the structure of your show while sounding relaxed and in the moment
- Trust that what you’re saying is worth listening to
- Put something you’ve created out into the world for judgement
That’s not natural.
It’s a skill.
So when people say “I’m not good enough”, what they’re often noticing is the gap between how they want to sound and how they sound right now.
That gap isn’t failure, it’s awareness.
And awareness is the thing that actually allows improvement to happen.
Why obsessing over confidence backfires
The mistake most people make at this point is trying to fix the feeling instead of building the skill and capability required to feel like you’re doing it well.
They start monitoring themselves too closely.
Overthinking every sentence.
Second-guessing their tone mid-record.
And ironically, that’s when people sound the least natural.
Not because they lack confidence, but because they’re trying to perform being confident instead of developing the necessary skill.
The hosts who sound “effortless” aren’t immune to self-doubt.
They’ve just learned how to focus on the work instead of the feeling.
And that matters if you want to actually be, and sound, in the moment.
Confidence comes after you’re competent
In podcasting, confidence is rarely something you start with.
It’s something that arrives after:
- Repetition
- Listening back
- Making small adjustments
- Learning what works for you and your audience
Most people assume they need to feel confident before they can sound good.
But in reality, it works the other way around.
You get better first.
Then you feel more confident.
And if you’re feeling a bit uncomfortable right now, that usually means you’re exactly where you should be.
What to take from this
If podcasting feels harder than you expected, or more exposing than you planned for, that doesn’t mean you’re doing it wrong.
It means you’re learning something that requires judgement, restraint and practice.
So hang in there.
If this kind of thinking is helpful, I share it weekly in my newsletter and if you want an objective take on where your strengths already are and what’s actually worth working on next, that’s exactly what I do in my 1:1 coaching sessions.
